Key takeaways
- Architectural shingles offer the best balance of cost and looks for most homes.
- Metal costs more up front and can last much longer.
- Both need correct flashing and ventilation to perform.
- Look at samples on your own house before you decide.
Most homes in Middle Tennessee have asphalt shingles, and metal is growing in popularity. Neither is better for everyone.
Architectural shingles
They are thick, layered and available in many colors. They cost less than metal, are quick to install and are easy to repair. Their lifespan depends on the product, the ventilation and the weather.
Metal roofing
Panels shed rain, snow and leaves and can last much longer than shingles. They cost more up front, and the look suits farmhouses, modern homes and porches especially well.
Weather in our area
Hail, wind and heavy rain all test a roof. Shingles can be bruised by hail and lifted by wind if poorly fastened. Metal can dent under large hail, though the dents are often cosmetic. Both need proper fastening.
Noise, heat and upkeep
With solid decking and underlayment, rain on metal is not much louder than rain on shingles. Both need clear gutters and valleys. Metal needs fewer repairs, while shingles are easier to patch.
How to choose
Think about how long you will stay, your budget and the look you want. Try both in our Roof Studio, then ask for samples.
Related services
Questions about your own roof? Call or text 615-431-3789, or use the quote form below.